Harvard and the ETF Ecosystem

Harvard and the ETF Ecosystem

Readers of TETF.Index Weekly know that at Toroso we are obsessed with ETF statistics about the ETF Ecosystem, but sometimes it is more about the “Who than the What” that makes an ecosystem successful; especially when it is the people who are the core asset.

It is somewhat ironic that the ETF industry is an “asset light business model” – meaning that dollars invested are in people and products and not in hard assets. Arguably this may be part of the reason why the financial services industry attracts aggressive, innovative entrepreneurial thinkers who apparently are mostly well educated. Of the 12 Founders, Chairmen, and CEOs in the ETF ecosystem, there are 5 degrees from Harvard and 3 Degrees from Stamford. Moreover, a quick review of the potential second in command include an additional 4 degrees from Harvard, i.e. Mary Erdoes at JP Morgan, Robert Kapito from Blackrock and 2 from Mortimer Buckley at Vanguard.

In our review, we also note that the tenure of these key players is unusually long and empowered the cultures of these firms to think long term.  Founders Charles Schwab (SCHW), Larry Fink (BLK) and Jonathan Steinberg (WETF) date back over 30 years. Henry Fernandez (MSCI) and Craig Spechter (ICE) built their businesses in 20 and 18 years, respectively.   From glancing at the chart below, most have spent at least 10 years at the firm they lead, including Jamie Dimon (JPM), Lloyd Blankfein (GS), and Martin Flanagan (IVZ).

Symbol College School

These leaders are clearly committed to driving the success of the profitability of their firms and capitalizing on the ETF ecosystem. Moreover, while they have different degrees of exposure to the ETF industry, their market share gains in the ETF ecosystem has been a result of a core belief in growth in the industry as it provides a value client proposition that is meaningfully better than antiquated alternatives. In addition, according to Bloomberg, it is clear that these leaders are big believers in themselves and the cultures they have created. It is evident that most of their net worth’s are invested in their own stocks. Again, sometimes it is about the WHO not the WHAT, but this commonality in the TETF.Index is arguably not a coincidence. These executives are outspoken, hard-driving visionaries with a capitalistic mission.

The TETF.Index does not include Fidelity’s Abigail Johnson (Harvard) or Vanguard’s Frederick McNabb  (Wharton) because those companies are not public, but it is worth noting that the top 10 holdings represent nearly 60% of the Index. We include these two individuals in our educational count and their importance in the ETF Ecosystem is not unnoticed, but as private companies, their value cannot be a part of the benchmark.

What will be the legacy that these leaders leave? We are big advocates at Toroso for  Women in ETFs (WE) and we expect this establishment to play a key role in the diversification of the industry and this means products like SPDR Gender Diversity (SHE), ImpactShares YWCA Women’s  (WOMN), and Impact Shares NAACP Minority (NACP) are only a reflection of demand. The future of the financial services industry must be more than just Robo Advisors and Artificial Intelligence. Our bet, through the creation of the TETF.Index, is that that these leaders, who every day see the value of their ownership go up and down in the elevator, will embrace diversity because financial service stocks follow innovation, profitability and growth. The ETF evolution has always been about a revolution and change. Voting with their own personal ownership these leaders see a call to action that is aligned with investing with success and building shareholder value.

Source of KPIs: Toroso Investments Security Master, as of September 10, 2018
 ETF LAUNCHES
First Trust Dorsey Wright Momt & Val ETF DVLU
FirstTrustDorseyWrightMomt&LwVolatil ETF DVOL
Vanguard Total World Bond ETF BNDW
Defiance Quantum ETF QTUM

INDEX PERFORMANCE DATA

Returns as of September 10, 2018.
Inception Date: April 4, 2017. Index performance is for informational purposes only and does not represent the ETF.
Indexes are unmanaged and one cannot invest directly in an index.
Past performance is NOT indicative of future results, which can vary.

TETF INDEX PERFORMANCE VS LEADING FINANCIAL INDEXES

As of September 10, 2018

TOP 10 HOLDINGS PERFORMANCE

BOTTOM 10 HOLDINGS PERFORMANCE

As of September 10, 2018. Source: Morningstar Direct.